Monkey Business (1931)

Though most people site Duck Soup or A Night at the Opera as their favorite Marx Brothers movie (I love both those movies a lot  by the way), my personal favorite is Monkey Business. This film is so fast paced and full of jokes, yet almost every single one of them hits perfectly. This movie features the great skit where all four of the brothers try to inmate Maurice Chevalier (which has to rank as among the funniest skits in movie history), Groucho and Thelma Todd have great chemistry (she would only appear in one more Marx Brothers movie, Horsefeathers), there is a brilliantly surreal sequence in which Harpo interrupts a Punch and Judy show that doesn't seem to have any puppeteers and it has one of my favorite Groucho lines "Madam, you're making history. In fact, you're making me, and I wish you'd keep my hands to yourself". Also helping make this film great is that Zeppo is actually given some good scenes here and he pulls them off very well (making me wish he was given more to do in other Marx Brothers movies).

Monkey Business was the brothers' third movie and their first one written specificly for the screen. Their two previous films, The Coconuts and Animal Crackers had been two of the brothers' successes on Broadway. Since these were hits on Broadway, it was assumed they would probably have success with them on the movie screen and that ended up being correct. Those movies were huge successes.

Writer S.J. Perelman had written a book called Dawn Ginsbergh's Revenge, which Groucho really liked. Groucho sent a complimentary letter to Perelman and asked to meet him backstage (the brothers were still on Broadway at this time), and Perelman said he would enjoy writing for the brothers. He was assigned to co-write (with W.B. Johnstone, who wrote the brothers' first stage success, I'll Say It Is) a radio script for the brothers, this would end up not happening because of the difficultly of the non-speaking Harpo being on radio. However the basic story idea of the Marxes as stowaways became the basis for this film in which Perelman would be a writer. However despite Groucho being impressed with Perelman' book, he wasn't as impressed with the script. His response can be summed up in two words "It stinks". Groucho often stated that the brothers in reality adlibbed nearly all of the funniest jokes in this movie and the next film Horsefeathers (also written by Perelman) and little of what Perelman wrote ended up in either script. The director of both films, Norman Z. McLeod, agreed that there was a lot of adlibbing on both the movies, and McLeod felt these adlibs were funnier than anything in the script. Groucho would later state about Perelman "...he is a great writer with a brilliant comic mind that didn't always mesh well with the lunacies of the Marx Brothers."

This film has inspired debate among Marx Brothers fans. It begins with a man telling the captain that there are four stowaways on the ship, but no one has seen them. When asked how he knows there are four, he states that they were singing Sweet Adline. Then the film cuts to four barrels and we hear Sweet Adline being sung, and after the song the Marx Brothers pop out of each. Now the debate has to do with whether there are three or four voices singing and if we actually hear Harpo's voice. Unfortunately I do not know the answer to this.

This film was not surprisingly a hit at both the box office and with critics. Now the story is simply an excuse for comedy, and it is impossible to properly analyze why the Marx Brothers are so funny. So just watch the movie for yourself and laugh yourself silly, you won't regret it.

-Michael J. Ruhland

Resources Used
http://www.tcm.com/this-month/article/290225%7C86548/Monkey-Business.html